回复：reddit上的一篇评价

[–]HaagenDazs 1 指標 1小時前
Paula Patton looks nothing like Zoe Saldana. They are both black, but that's about it.
永久連結

[–]daemoneyes 1 指標 1小時前
Is it a movie you would see a second time/recommend to friends?
Is it more LOTR or The Hobbit in terms of scope and ambitions?
Is it a fun movie? i ask because wow/warcraft had a somewhat cartoony animation so i hope it's not all dark and gloomy.
How's the CGI? while again wow is kinda cartonish did the CGI break immersion for you?
Is there a Leroy moment? :) don't want the details , just a yes/no answer
永久連結

[–]PeterJAK 1 指標 1小時前
I would assume there's no Leeroy moment, since that happened in World of Warcraft and this movie is based on Warcraft: Orcs and Humans.
永久連結上層留言
[–]metanoiaisn 1 指標 1小時前
He means as a WoW easter egg which Duncan Jones said he would add in the movie.
永久連結上層留言

还好吧，有些人也会要求高，就算是粉丝也一样，要不然也不会超出预期给个中等分了

还行吧，此人属于打分苛刻的，在他来看，69已经属于不错的分数了

到家了。。我试着翻译一下吧

其实这人给分很有意思，我估计有一些公认的巨制到他那也最多给个80分吧，比如泰坦尼克号

感觉网友们把问题都问得差不多了。各方面都OK，就是演员的表演有点弱。剧情还凑合，谈不上很好但也不差。他给的分数是中庸.

看了一段，实在太多，貌似就一句：超出预期～特效挺好，我给69

我删除了我最初的帖子，因为我讨厌这个标题。此外，这是一个不能给人留下深刻印象的帖子，我更擅长于回答特定的问题。
首先，一个免责声明：我不是一个电影评论家，不是记者。我最初的评论可以在我最近的帖子历史里找到。我要感谢我的女朋友能让我看到SCREENER（电影发行用于促销目的的DVD？）我从业于建筑，不会从发帖中得到好处。其次，我在加州，现在是11点45了，我明天8点有很多工作要做。我希望的是这个帖子能得到足够的问题，然后我明天就能写一个简单的，不剧透的电影感想。写评论可能是个不妥的用词，我肯定我立刻会被偏见的当成是一个WOW玩家。但是，我也看见了油管上那个给了8.9分的人的帖子，并且人们很快把他召唤出来了。我从事建筑业，所以请把它当成是一种安慰，我没有任何兴趣倾向于这样或那样的方式。
MR GOODNOODLE的了解情况的电影分值范围是60-70之间（100分），我会给69分。因为这比我预期的要享受得多。视觉效果(CGI、服饰、编排)确实让我对分数有了倾斜，现实点的话给65会更客观。很多人也许会给更低，我并不怀疑。我的观点是我享受了它的90%因为每一个场景我都没有拆开来看。
有一些事情把分数降到了50。但是我确实必须把这部电影分成一个曲线等级（见下面的视觉效果）。我不能不考虑整个电影团队的辛勤工作，并且他们的工作完成得非常棒。我想把这个电影分成优点部分和缺点部分，但是我没有一个记事本和播放/暂停键。
剧情：
我仍然不确定故事情节，故事一直在跳来跳去，如果你没玩过WOW，我不确信你能明白是怎么回事，我唯一能描述剧情的方法就是它就像是一块牢不可破的浮岩：它充满了漏洞，但是结构却很稳定，它很弱但是它仍然完成了这个故事。
编排还有严格的来说属于视觉范畴的方面：
非常棒！绝对精彩！我想我已不用多说。每一个截图可能像是被撕裂的，吹毛求疵的人可能会很不屑，但是最终的结果却是惊人的。几个独立的场景真的进入到脑海中，并且牵涉到角色自己的动画。我不想毁了这部电影，所以就因为好奇问问。

太长了不想翻了。。。。要去吃饭了
后面还讲了迦罗娜的化妆服装问题，自己喜欢维京海盗但是不喜欢洛萨的演员，讲到对白推动剧情发展，讲了古尔丹的几个场景起了鸡皮疙瘩，并剧透生命汲取才是电影中用得最多的魔法，除开麦迪文和卡德加每10分钟一次的传送术

谁把重要的评论也翻译一下咯

是否可总结为视觉效果很好，剧情对非魔兽玩家不容易理解，但还是完整的讲了一个故事？

Watched an early screening in LA(Student from EU here) a few hours ago.
I was sceptic at first but all my fears were blown away. Visuals are fantastic propably the best CGI i have seen since the dawn of the apes.10-15 minutes into the movie and u forget the X characters are CGI. CHoreography as OP states is top tier
As far as human acting is concerned it is GOOD it is not exceptional but it will deffo not let a bitter taste to u after the movie ends. Ben Foster- Travis Fimmel are all great. Special mention Ryan Robbins is fuking epic on that small role, he plays it perfectly. Garona was ok, DOminic Copper should've been a little more adamant he didnt have so much nerve as kIng Layne.
As far orcs are concerned u will be blown away,every single one of them is amazingly portraited, u can see the years of the work they put on them really to shine. DUrotan (Draka what a pleasant surprise). GUl' Dan!! Orgrimm...every each of them is like pretty fucking cool.
Pace of the movie is very very good, Duncan Jones has put some subplotes which make the movie better digestable for audience with no idea about Warcraft without ruining the plot.
I am not a reviewer either even though a movie maniac myself.
I would rate the movie around 77-80 of 100 and that trying to be as strict as possible.Movie was overall fantastic, the overall human casting could've been better and if the movie suceeds it will propably be better since everyone knows behind the scenes that the huge chunk of money went to the CGI creation. THAT being said the cast does its job very good, u wont have any bitter sensation after the movie ends.
Sorry for my mediocre ENglish
我再补充一个另外一个人的评价
也是特效非常棒