Edwin van der Sar
          Hardly tested all night    7
Wes Brown
          Subbed off due to injury    6   
Rio Ferdinand
          Marshalled Kevin Doyle with great skill    7     
Patrice Evra
          Shuttled down the flank, excellent on defence and attack    8
Nemanja Vidic
          Solid, let down by a few rash challenges    6
Antonio Valencia
          Always willing to take on his marker, better final ball needed    7
Michael Carrick
          Distributed the ball well    7  
Paul Scholes
          Grabbed the winner, covered every blade of grass    8
Darron Gibson
          Not his best showing    6  
Dimitar Berbatov
          Got into some good areas without looking like scoring    7  
Nani
          Final ball is still lacking    5