4. Forms of Address 3
It goes almost without saying that rules like these cause some confusion about what to call people.
For example, a university student may be visiting a counselor for help with study skills. The counselor, who is only a little older than the student, calls her “Susanne” from the first meeting. What does the student call the counselor?
“Ms Green” may seem too formal, given the similarity in age, but “Janet” may be too familiar, given the counselor’s role. If Janet Green does not give any indication of what she wants to be called, the student is likely not to use any name at all. In fact, it is not unusual for people in these sorts of role relationships to go on for months without calling one another by any name, which can make situations such as telephone calls and public meetings rather awkward, to say the least.
Cultures influence communication styles. Although this point may seem obvious, cultural styles can and do create misunderstandings in conversations among people from different cultures.
A conversation between an Italian and an American.
The Italian made a strong political statement with which he knew his American friend would disagree. The Italian wanted to involve the American in a lively discussion. The American, rather than openly disagreeing, said, “Well, everyone is entitled to an opinion. I accept that your opinion is different from mine.” The Italian responded, “That’s all you have to say about it?” In general, the American did not enjoy verbal conflicts over politics or anything else. The Italian actually became angry when the American refused to get involved in the discussion. He later explained to the American, “A conversation isn’t fun unless it becomes heated.”
What does this example say about culture and its influence on communication?
Surely, there are many Americans who do get involved in verbal conflicts over politics, just as there are some Italians who would not become involved.
However, the above conversation represents types of communication patterns that are related to cultural differences.
In her book You Just Don’t Understand, the sociolinguistic researcher Deborah Tannen discusses the notion that people from some cultures value “high involvement” conversation patterns, while others value “high considerateness” patterns.
1.1 “High involvement” styles
Many people from cultures that prefer “high involvement” styles tend to:
1.talk more;
2.interrupt more;
3.expect to be interrupted;
4.talk more loudly at times; and
5.talk more quickly than those from cultures favoring “high considerateness” styles.
Many “high involvement” speakers enjoy arguments and might even think that others are not interested if they are not ready to engage in a heated discussion.
The cultures that Tannen characterizes as having “high involvement” conversational styles include Russian, Italian, Greek, Spanish, South American, Arab, and African
1.2 “High considerateness” styles
On the other hand, people from cultures that favor “high considerateness” styles tend to:
1.speak one at a time;
2.use polite listening sounds;
3.refrain from interruption; and
It goes almost without saying that rules like these cause some confusion about what to call people.
For example, a university student may be visiting a counselor for help with study skills. The counselor, who is only a little older than the student, calls her “Susanne” from the first meeting. What does the student call the counselor?
“Ms Green” may seem too formal, given the similarity in age, but “Janet” may be too familiar, given the counselor’s role. If Janet Green does not give any indication of what she wants to be called, the student is likely not to use any name at all. In fact, it is not unusual for people in these sorts of role relationships to go on for months without calling one another by any name, which can make situations such as telephone calls and public meetings rather awkward, to say the least.
Cultures influence communication styles. Although this point may seem obvious, cultural styles can and do create misunderstandings in conversations among people from different cultures.
A conversation between an Italian and an American.
The Italian made a strong political statement with which he knew his American friend would disagree. The Italian wanted to involve the American in a lively discussion. The American, rather than openly disagreeing, said, “Well, everyone is entitled to an opinion. I accept that your opinion is different from mine.” The Italian responded, “That’s all you have to say about it?” In general, the American did not enjoy verbal conflicts over politics or anything else. The Italian actually became angry when the American refused to get involved in the discussion. He later explained to the American, “A conversation isn’t fun unless it becomes heated.”
What does this example say about culture and its influence on communication?
Surely, there are many Americans who do get involved in verbal conflicts over politics, just as there are some Italians who would not become involved.
However, the above conversation represents types of communication patterns that are related to cultural differences.
In her book You Just Don’t Understand, the sociolinguistic researcher Deborah Tannen discusses the notion that people from some cultures value “high involvement” conversation patterns, while others value “high considerateness” patterns.
1.1 “High involvement” styles
Many people from cultures that prefer “high involvement” styles tend to:
1.talk more;
2.interrupt more;
3.expect to be interrupted;
4.talk more loudly at times; and
5.talk more quickly than those from cultures favoring “high considerateness” styles.
Many “high involvement” speakers enjoy arguments and might even think that others are not interested if they are not ready to engage in a heated discussion.
The cultures that Tannen characterizes as having “high involvement” conversational styles include Russian, Italian, Greek, Spanish, South American, Arab, and African
1.2 “High considerateness” styles
On the other hand, people from cultures that favor “high considerateness” styles tend to:
1.speak one at a time;
2.use polite listening sounds;
3.refrain from interruption; and